Why Choose Otto Insurance Group in Westerville, Ohio for Your Insurance Needs

The team at Otto Insurance Group assists our clients with finding the best insurance options for themselves and their loved ones.

We understand that having the right insurance policy that fits your needs and budget is essential. Feel protected and get the support you need when you partner with Otto Insurance Group.

Get a Quote
Westerville, OH
angle background graphic
Contact Info

Office Hours

Monday - Friday: 8:30AM - 5:00PM

Saturday & Sunday: Closed

Otto Insurance Group Logo
Our Team

Meet the Team Members of Otto Insurance Group in Westerville

Otto Insurance Group is comprised of highly experienced and qualified insurance professionals. We're dedicated to working with you to find a policy that protects you, your loved ones, and your assets. We strive to find a policy that provides you with comprehensive coverage while meeting your long-term needs.

Mark Otto
President
Mark Betts
Vice President
Michael Ross
Sr. Risk Advisor
Stephanie Hasson
Director of Commercial Services
Jodi McNamara
Personal Account Manager
Rachel Ford
Sr. Risk Advisor
Brandon Lawson
Risk Advisor
Taylor Dyson
Risk Advisor
Amy Hanna
Director of Operations
Tara Hock
Commercial Account Manager
Marjorie Wilson
Director of Personal Accounts
Jill Swimm
Personal Account Manager
Sydney Spaulding
Administrative Assistant

We Love Helping Westerville Locals

Westerville, Ohio is located just outside of Columbus and offers a cozy small-town vibe combined with the benefits of city life. Westerville is historically rich, being the birthplace of Prohibition and other significant movements. With a thriving arts community, unique local restaurants and breweries, a top-ranked liberal arts college, and a wealth of outdoor spaces, it's no wonder Westerville was named America's Best Suburb by Movoto in 2013.

Community involvement is highly valued in Westerville, and the city has a dedicated program to create events for residents to connect and engage. From adult Easter egg hunts to "mommy and me" tea parties, the city prioritizes its residents. This strong sense of community is a key part of Westerville's culture.

Otto Insurance Group is proud to be a staple in this vibrant community. Our commitment to providing top-quality insurance services, as well as our active participation in local events and initiatives, makes us a trusted partner for residents of Westerville. We believe in supporting the community that supports us and are dedicated to contributing to the town's reputation for being a welcoming and supportive place to live.

Get an Insurance Quote From Otto Insurance Group Today

Whether you need auto insurance, life insurance, or health insurance quote, we're here to help. Request a quote for the insurance policy you need through Otto Insurance Group. We'll match you with the best policy possible.

Customer Testimonials

See what our many happy customers have to say about us.

No items found.
"
You always help us with payments and always so very nice thank you

Leonard K.

"
"Brandon and this agency are top notch. The client services are impressive and Brandon is professional, kind and detailed. Highly recommend."

Sheri Nash

"
Very prompt customer service any time that we need a document.

Amy R.

"
Your personal care and attention my needs as well as my family’s.

Arthur S

"
Amazing service, consistent communication and always willing to help. Mike Ross and Stephanie are on top of their game and always there to help.

Timothy S.

"
My AIG team has been very supportive and communcative throughout my time with them. I have had multiple insured properties and assets in two states and AIG has provided exact and appropriate coverage. Over the years, I have used multiple insurance companies and AIG has excelled in price and service.

Norman R.

"
Prompt service for all my insurance needs no matter how big our small, are treated with the same urgency. This has made my insurance task list very easy to check off.

Jason E.

"
Rachel has been an integral part in my business for years and I refer her to anyone who will listen. She is always available and has become an asset!

Brad C.

"
Rachel Ford is fantastic. Friendly, competent, efficient, 12 out of 10!

Daniel R.

"
It doesn't matter how complicated I get, you guys always try to meet my expectations.

Betty M.

"
Quick response to my email and concern

Constance M.

"
Very easy to communicate with you and you solved my problems very quickly. Additionally, you were able to give me better deals and more convenient options.

Federico P.

"
I like working with a company that can provide options from multiple carriers and of course Rachel! She is responsive and great to work with.

Tanya C.

"
Every time I call Brandon he takes care of everything I need. And also if I refer him he calls everyone back as soon as he possibly can. Also if he cannot help him for any reason he always follows up. Which is very rare these days.

Scott F.

"
I enjoy working and talking with Mike Ross.

Chad C.

Customer testimonials

See what our many happy customers have to say about us.

"
Very easy to communicate with you and you solved my problems very quickly. Additionally, you were able to give me better deals and more convenient options.

Federico P.

"
It’s a local insurance company and I have gotten to know most of the people that work there. They are friendly and willing to answer all my questions in a professional manner. I have been with this insurance co for approximately 40 years.

Freda W.

"
You guys have kept me insured for over 20 years and have always been great and number one at customer service. I’ve never had any problems with you. Great job!

JJ S.

"
Prompt service for all my insurance needs no matter how big our small, are treated with the same urgency. This has made my insurance task list very easy to check off.

Jason E.

"
You guys were on it 100% on what type of insurance I needed for my business and you responded quickly and got it done right away

Lee D.

"
Great customer service and responsiveness, friendly and professional staff

Lynn A

"
Great service, Work quickly and always looking out for my best interest

Marvin I.

"
We have been customers for 35 years, actually the only insurance agency I’ve ever dealt with because you are that good! I have referred friends for years because your service and customer care is unbeatable! Claims have always been resolved quickly and with absolutely no hassle. We have , and are sure will continue to be, very satisfied.

Michael S.

"
Very responsive and helpful along with unbelievable savings!

Patrick W.

"
I like that each year you shop around to find me the lowest premium without me asking.

Tracey C.

"
Very easy to communicate with you and you solved my problems very quickly. Additionally, you were able to give me better deals and more convenient options.

Federico P.

"
It’s a local insurance company and I have gotten to know most of the people that work there. They are friendly and willing to answer all my questions in a professional manner. I have been with this insurance co for approximately 40 years.

Freda W.

"
You guys have kept me insured for over 20 years and have always been great and number one at customer service. I’ve never had any problems with you. Great job!

JJ S.

"
Prompt service for all my insurance needs no matter how big our small, are treated with the same urgency. This has made my insurance task list very easy to check off.

Jason E.

"
You guys were on it 100% on what type of insurance I needed for my business and you responded quickly and got it done right away

Lee D.

"
Great customer service and responsiveness, friendly and professional staff

Lynn A

"
Great service, Work quickly and always looking out for my best interest

Marvin I.

"
We have been customers for 35 years, actually the only insurance agency I’ve ever dealt with because you are that good! I have referred friends for years because your service and customer care is unbeatable! Claims have always been resolved quickly and with absolutely no hassle. We have , and are sure will continue to be, very satisfied.

Michael S.

"
Very responsive and helpful along with unbelievable savings!

Patrick W.

"
I like that each year you shop around to find me the lowest premium without me asking.

Tracey C.

Request a Quote

Enter your info below and we will get back to you with an estimate as soon as we can.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
close iconclose icon

Account Login

Sign in to manage your account.

close iconclose icon