Why Choose Otto Insurance Group in Newark, Ohio for Your Insurance Needs

The team at Otto Insurance Group assists our clients with finding the best insurance options for themselves and their loved ones.

We understand that having the right insurance policy that fits your needs and budget is essential. Feel protected and get the support you need when you partner with Otto Insurance Group.

Get a Quote
Newark, OH
angle background graphic
Contact Info

Office Hours

Monday - Friday: 9AM -5PM

Saturday & Sunday: Closed

Otto Insurance Group Logo
Our Team

Meet the Team Members of Otto Insurance Group in Newark

Otto Insurance Group is comprised of highly experienced and qualified insurance professionals. We're dedicated to working with you to find a policy that protects you, your loved ones, and your assets. We strive to find a policy that provides you with comprehensive coverage while meeting your long-term needs.

Brad Feightner
Sr. Risk Advisor
Marc Scarrett
Risk Advisor
Trevor Garber
Risk Advisor
Jake Nelson
Risk Advisor
Robin Bradley
Personal Account Manager
Chrissie Fischer
Risk Advisor
Dustin Neely
Risk Advisor

We Love Helping Newark Locals Find the Best Insurance

Otto Insurance Group is a staple in the community of Newark, located 35 miles east of Columbus and nestled along the edge of the Appalachian plateau in Licking County. With roots dating back to the early 1800s, this bustling village has a rich history and a thriving culture.

One of the town's defining features is the Newark Earthworks, a series of mounds built by the Hopewell Indians and now preserved by the Ohio History Connection. Otto Insurance Group takes pride in supporting the preservation of this important piece of local history.

Another popular attraction in Newark is the Dawes Arboretum, an outdoor museum of trees with over 12 miles of trails. Otto Insurance Group is a proud sponsor of the arboretum, helping to maintain its natural beauty and provide a peaceful escape for the community.

The performing arts scene in Newark is also thriving, thanks in part to the restored Midland Theatre. As a sponsor of the arts, Otto Insurance Group is dedicated to supporting the local performing arts community and providing a space for residents and visitors to enjoy live music and other cultural events. Whether supporting local history, the beauty of nature, or the arts, Otto Insurance Group is a proud and integral part of the Newark community.

Get an Insurance Quote From Otto Insurance Group Today

Whether you need auto insurance, life insurance, or health insurance quote, we're here to help. Request a quote for the insurance policy you need through Otto Insurance Group. We'll match you with the best policy possible.

Customer Testimonials

See what our many happy customers have to say about us.

Customer review

Chris Slayman

July 28, 2023
"

I've been with Otto Insurance since the name change from the Associated Insurance Companies of Newark, and before that. . . Scarrett Insurance in the same building at 1335 Granville Road in Newark.  

I haven't known Robin Bradley for too long, but probably since the time she came aboard the Newark office.  The first thing that I've come to appreciate over the years is the prompt service and prompt communication replies.  I really haven't had to have too much communication with Robin, primarily since we didn't have frequent changes to our policy and I've never in 25 years had to file a claim (knock on wood).  

But recently, my 20 year-old son needed to move to Virginia with the Navy (active duty) and needed a car.  Due to outrageous used car prices, it was worthwhile buying new.  He bought himself a brand new Civic, and mom and dad told him we would pay his car insurance, at least for the next few years.  When Robin returned the quote, I was not happy -  simply because of sticker-shock.  In hindsight, I should've known better, that this quote is simply what a 20 year old with a brand new car costs across the market.  I was a tad snippy with Robin, not because of anything she did but just out of being upset over rising costs everywhere for the American family.

Robin took my response like a champ, and not only was completely professional, but set out on a mission to find my family better rates.  Over the past several weeks, I know that she has spent a lot of time shopping for me and keeping me informed along the way of progress.  Today, she called me with great news of a new policy through Hanover, and saved us significant money.  In a time of inflation and rising costs, this was a relief.  

I just appreciate the effort, concern, dedication and great communication that I get from Robin Bradley in Newark.  She represents your company well!

"
Brad and the staff are always super friendly, very responsive and well informed in their industry. Great Job!

Patrick S.

"
Never had a problem with claims always very helpful

James W.

"
It’s a local insurance company and I have gotten to know most of the people that work there. They are friendly and willing to answer all my questions in a professional manner. I have been with this insurance co for approximately 40 years.

Freda W.

"
You guys have kept me insured for over 20 years and have always been great and number one at customer service. I’ve never had any problems with you. Great job!

JJ S.

"
Great personal service!

Thomas G.

"
Brad got the best possible rates for our situation concerning all our insurance services.

Amy B.

"

Chris Slayman

"
Very responsive and helpful along with unbelievable savings!

Patrick W.

"
We have been customers for 35 years, actually the only insurance agency I’ve ever dealt with because you are that good! I have referred friends for years because your service and customer care is unbeatable! Claims have always been resolved quickly and with absolutely no hassle. We have , and are sure will continue to be, very satisfied.

Michael S.

"
Brad is a top notch guy and terrific agent.

Cuz E.

Customer testimonials

See what our many happy customers have to say about us.

"
Very easy to communicate with you and you solved my problems very quickly. Additionally, you were able to give me better deals and more convenient options.

Federico P.

"
It’s a local insurance company and I have gotten to know most of the people that work there. They are friendly and willing to answer all my questions in a professional manner. I have been with this insurance co for approximately 40 years.

Freda W.

"
You guys have kept me insured for over 20 years and have always been great and number one at customer service. I’ve never had any problems with you. Great job!

JJ S.

"
Prompt service for all my insurance needs no matter how big our small, are treated with the same urgency. This has made my insurance task list very easy to check off.

Jason E.

"
You guys were on it 100% on what type of insurance I needed for my business and you responded quickly and got it done right away

Lee D.

"
Great customer service and responsiveness, friendly and professional staff

Lynn A

"
Great service, Work quickly and always looking out for my best interest

Marvin I.

"
We have been customers for 35 years, actually the only insurance agency I’ve ever dealt with because you are that good! I have referred friends for years because your service and customer care is unbeatable! Claims have always been resolved quickly and with absolutely no hassle. We have , and are sure will continue to be, very satisfied.

Michael S.

"
Very responsive and helpful along with unbelievable savings!

Patrick W.

"
I like that each year you shop around to find me the lowest premium without me asking.

Tracey C.

"
Very easy to communicate with you and you solved my problems very quickly. Additionally, you were able to give me better deals and more convenient options.

Federico P.

"
It’s a local insurance company and I have gotten to know most of the people that work there. They are friendly and willing to answer all my questions in a professional manner. I have been with this insurance co for approximately 40 years.

Freda W.

"
You guys have kept me insured for over 20 years and have always been great and number one at customer service. I’ve never had any problems with you. Great job!

JJ S.

"
Prompt service for all my insurance needs no matter how big our small, are treated with the same urgency. This has made my insurance task list very easy to check off.

Jason E.

"
You guys were on it 100% on what type of insurance I needed for my business and you responded quickly and got it done right away

Lee D.

"
Great customer service and responsiveness, friendly and professional staff

Lynn A

"
Great service, Work quickly and always looking out for my best interest

Marvin I.

"
We have been customers for 35 years, actually the only insurance agency I’ve ever dealt with because you are that good! I have referred friends for years because your service and customer care is unbeatable! Claims have always been resolved quickly and with absolutely no hassle. We have , and are sure will continue to be, very satisfied.

Michael S.

"
Very responsive and helpful along with unbelievable savings!

Patrick W.

"
I like that each year you shop around to find me the lowest premium without me asking.

Tracey C.

Request a Quote

Enter your info below and we will get back to you with an estimate as soon as we can.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
close iconclose icon

Account Login

Sign in to manage your account.

close iconclose icon